European officials are under pressure to decide on using Russia’s frozen assets to support the Ukrainian defence, during unprecedented calls from the United States.
At a critical summit in Brussels, EU member states will be expected to fulfill a commitment to find urgently needed funds for Ukraine, as Kyiv is under the threat to lose ground while Russian forces eke out advances on the battlefield.
“There is no more important demonstration of European defence than supporting Ukraine’s fight,” stated the head of the EU executive, who went on to say that “the next days will be crucial in securing this.”
She added that Europe must assume responsibility for its own defence in a world she characterized as “dangerous and transactional,” emphasizing: “That is not an option. It is a necessity.”
Funding Options on the Agenda
Earlier, a pair of main proposals were put forward to fund Ukraine’s pressing military and reconstruction needs for the coming years:
- Joint EU issuing of debt.
- A so-called “reparations loan” backed against Russia’s immobilized funds within the Union.
Legal and Monetary Hurdles
The Belgian government, which holds the bulk of the €210 billion in immobilized Russian state funds within the EU, has expressed concerns. It argues it does not have sufficient guarantees that other EU countries would come to its aid if the scheme collapsed, potentially sticking Brussels with a multibillion-euro liability.
Compounding these concerns, the Russian Central Bank announced it was seeking massive compensation against the Brussels-based clearing house holding most of these assets. Belgium also fears that legal systems in countries allied to Russia could move to seize European holdings in retaliation.
Crucial National Stances
The Italian government has positioned itself as an important voice of caution. The prime minister argued that using Russia’s immobilized assets absent a ironclad legal basis would hand Moscow a major propaganda victory. Like Belgium, Italy argues that joint EU debt issuance would be a safer method.
“Italy, naturally, hold sacred the principle that Russia should be the one to pay for the rebuilding of the nation it invaded, but this outcome must be accomplished with a solid legal basis,” she informed lawmakers.
Germany stated a commitment to render up to €90bn in Russian assets “usable for Ukraine’s defense.” He put the odds of securing an agreement at “fifty-fifty.”
He informed lawmakers the amount could fund the Ukrainian army for “a minimum of another two years,” and its deployment would send a clear message to the Russian leadership.
The Proposed “Reparations Loan” Mechanism
According to the proposed scheme, the EU would grant Kyiv with a substantial loan funded through borrowing. This loan would solely be settled if and when Moscow was forced to pay reparations to Ukraine.
European diplomats insist that Russia’s ownership claim on the immobilized funds would not be affected. Moscow, however, argues the action amounts to theft and has vowed to retaliate.
Political Hurdles and Consensus
Diplomats engaged in the summit have suggested the reparations loan is the only viable path forward, as using the Union's common budget would require unanimity.
Hungary, which is opposed to aid for Ukraine, has promised to block any attempt to use the EU budget as collateral for a Kyiv loan. The compensation loan, by contrast, would need just a majority of EU member states.
“A vast majority of member states favour the reparations loan,” commented one senior EU official. “Any potential alternative that would require consensus, I don’t think is achievable so we are back into the reparations loan.”
Recently, the EU used emergency powers to permanently immobilize the Russian assets, averting the risk of losing control on them due to a possible block from a Kremlin-friendly government when restrictions come up for extension.
Belgium has suggested that such emergency powers could also be used to create an EU loan for Ukraine secured against the budget, circumventing the need for full agreement. But, other member states argue that would be a legal twist too far.